Time management and planning

Why reminders stop working, and how to set ones that do

Published 8 min read
Why reminders stop working, and how to set ones that do: an illustrated guide from Taskling, the ADHD daily planner

Most people set reminders, swipe them away, and forget the task anyway. This is not a personal failing. Research on alert fatigue shows that people learn to ignore alerts when there are too many or they come at the wrong time, and studies on cue based reminders show that the best reminders are distinctive and arrive at the moment you can act. Fewer, better timed and more specific reminders beat many vague ones.

Key takeaways
  • Too many alerts teach the brain to ignore them, which is called alert fatigue.
  • A reminder works best when it arrives at the moment you can act on it.
  • Distinctive cues are noticed more than ones that blend in.
  • Say exactly what to do in the reminder, not just the name of the task.

The swipe and forget problem

You set a reminder: "Call the doctor". It pops up at 10am while you are in a meeting. You swipe it away, meaning to call later. Later never comes. You had a reminder and you still forgot.

This happens because a reminder only does half the job. It brings a task to mind, but if you cannot act right then, the task has to be held in working memory again, which is exactly the problem the reminder was meant to solve. For people with ADHD, who often find holding intentions harder, a badly timed reminder is close to no reminder at all.

Quote card from the Taskling guide Why reminders stop working, and how to set ones that do: Most people set reminders, swipe them away, and forget the task anyway.
From the guide “Why reminders stop working, and how to set ones that do”

Alert fatigue: why we tune them out

Hospitals have studied this closely, because missed alarms can be dangerous. When clinicians face many alerts, especially ones that are not important, they become desensitised and start overriding them. This is called alert fatigue. One study found primary care clinicians were more likely to override alerts when several appeared for the same patient.

Your phone does the same thing to you on a smaller scale. If you get dozens of notifications a day, a reminder is one more buzz among many, and your brain learns to dismiss buzzes without reading them. Every reminder you ignore makes it easier to ignore the next one.

What makes a reminder work

Research by Todd Rogers and Katherine Milkman on what they call reminders through association found that cues work best when they are distinctive compared with everything else around them, and when they appear at the place and time where you can act. In one experiment, people who were given a distinctive object as a cue to remember a small task were far more likely to complete it than those without the cue.

Put together, the research suggests three rules: send fewer reminders so each one matters, time them for the moment of action, and make them stand out.

Eight rules for better reminders

  1. Remind for the start, not the deadline. Not "report due Friday" but "Wednesday 10am: open the report and write the headings".
  2. Write the action, not the topic. "Call the clinic on 020 7946 0000 and ask for a new date" beats "doctor".
  3. Time it for when you can act. If you are at work until 5, a reminder at 5:15 to buy milk beats one at noon.
  4. Use places, not just times. A location reminder when you arrive home, or a physical cue on your shoes, links the task to the moment you can do it.
  5. Cut the noise. Turn off notifications from apps that are not important. Every useless buzz weakens the useful ones.
  6. Make important ones different. A different sound, a widget, a bright note. Distinctive cues get noticed.
  7. Do not snooze without a plan. If you cannot act, move it to a specific time instead of "later".
  8. Clear dead reminders weekly. A list of ignored reminders becomes background noise.
Try it in Taskling

In Taskling, each task can carry a reminder set to when you will actually do it, and the home screen widget keeps today's plan in sight without extra buzzing. Tadaa can turn "remind me to call mum tomorrow at 3" into a task with the right time. See the ADHD planner.

Quick answers

How many reminders is too many?

There is no magic number, but if you often swipe reminders without reading them, you have too many. Cut until each one gets your attention.

Are alarms better than notifications?

For things you must not miss, often yes, because they require action to stop. Use them sparingly so they keep their power.

Why do sticky notes stop working after a week?

They stop being distinctive. Move them, change their colour, or replace them to make them noticeable again.